The Presumed Innocent recently became the most-watched drama on Apple TV+. Based on the novel of the same name, the legal thriller delves into the story of Rusty Sabich (Gyllenhaal), a prosecutor accused of killing his colleague, whom he also had an affair with.
The series' tense courtroom scenes and powerful performances earned it a second season. While viewers wait for season 2, they can check out 10 great legal thrillers and dramas like Presumed Innocent, which can be streamed online today on platforms like Hulu, and more!
Candy
Like Presumed Innocent, Candy combines murder with a complicated love triangle. Based on a true story, the series follows Candy Montgomery (Jessica Biel), a suburban housewife accused of killing her neighbor, Betty Gore (Melanie Lynskey), while having an affair with Gore’s husband. The show boasts powerful performances from Biel and Lynskey, a dark true crime premise, and plenty of family drama.
Defending Jacob
Based on the book of the same name by William Landay, Defending Jacob follows Assistant District Attorney Andy Barber (Chris Evans), whose 14-year-old son, Jacob Barber (Jaden Martell), becomes the prime suspect in the death of a fellow high school student. Similar to Presume Innocent, Defending Jacob sees a man in the legal profession torn between doing his job and loyalty to his family, and the show also features an A-list cast and a deep dive into a murder mystery.
Eric
Eric is a psychological thriller that follows Vincent Anderson (Benedict Cumberbatch), a puppeteer who sets out to find his missing son. Meanwhile, Detective Michael Ledroit (McKinley Belcher III) navigates corruption in the New York Police Department to solve the case. Eric offers a more whimsical approach to crime than Presumed Innocent when Vincent begins conversing with his son’s imaginary friend. Still, it’s just as thrilling with its story of a family struggling under a crime case and deep corruption in the justice system.
Mare of Easttown
The critically acclaimed Mare of Easttown follows Detective Marianne "Mare" Sheehan (Kate Winslet), a woman hailed as a hero in her hometown, who cracks under the pressure of a homicide case and her family's turmoil. It’s an even more serious and female-focused series than Presumed Innocent, offering a career-best performance from Winslet and an unpredictable story that probes topics of abuse, addiction, and grief.
Reasonable Doubt
Both Reasonable Doubt and Presumed Innocent focus on flawed defense attorneys. Reasonable Doubt follows Jax Stewart (Emayatzy Corinealdi), a sharp and successful defense attorney who sometimes blurs the lines of work and personal life and has a penchant for drama. While the show has a more comedic tone than Presumed Innocent, both shows offer strong performances and a deep dive into the messy personal lives of two lawyers.
Suspicion
Suspicion is perfect for viewers who love the thrilling mystery at the center of Presumed Innocent. The series follows a group of four ordinary citizens who are suddenly accused of involvement in a high-profile kidnapping case. Like Presumed Innocent, the show is a fast-paced legal thriller that will leave viewers constantly second-guessing who is innocent.
The Crowded Room
The Crowded Room offers viewers a legal thriller with some intense courtroom scenes. The series follows investigator Rya Goodwin (Amanda Seyfried), who is tasked with acquitting her client, Danny Sullivan (Tom Holland), by using his dissociative identity disorder (DID) as a defense. It is a dark and thrilling legal drama about one man’s desperation to prove his innocence despite the odds against him.
The Undoing
Similar to Presumed Innocent, The Undoing takes advantage of its brilliant cast, with Nicole Kidman and Hugh Grant offering riveting performances. The series follows Grace Fraser (Kidman), a successful psychologist whose life turns upside down when her husband, Jonathan (Hugh Grant), is accused of killing his mistress. As a result, it’s almost like Presume Innocent but from the wife’s perspective and with plenty of its own unique twists and turns.
Under the Bridge
Under the Bridge is a true crime drama about Reena Virk (Vritika Gupta). Her small town is rattled when Reena disappears one day, but the case grows even more unsettling when the police realize the young ages of the main suspects. It boasts the same mystery and drama as Presumed Innocent but also offers a more nuanced look into crime and the factors that motivate it.
Your Honor
Your Honor follows Michael Desiato (Bryan Cranston), a father willing to do anything to protect his son, Adam (Hunter Doohan), after he’s involved in a hit-and-run accident. Presumed Innocent and Your Honor explore men willing to go to great lengths to protect themselves and their families. However, Your Honor also offers additional action as it frequently takes things outside the justice system.
Where to watch shows like Presumed Innocent online
Check out our list below to find out where you can stream these shows like Presumed Innocent in the United States.
